Restaurant Overview for Notaro in New York City, NY

Nestled in the heart of Murray Hill, Notaro offers an inviting atmosphere for fans of traditional Italian cuisine. With its cozy décor and a charming fireplace, this eatery promises a warm dining experience, whether for lunch or dinner. Reviews highlight the restaurant’s approachable menu and satisfactory service, making it a local favorite for over two decades. Patrons appreciate the restaurant’s calm environment, perfect for family gatherings or quiet dinners, though service quality can vary. Overall, Notaro is a reliable choice for both residents and visitors seeking classic Italian dishes in New York City.

Ambiance and Location

Prime Location in Murray Hill

This restaurant is situated at 635 2nd Ave, between 34th & 35th streets, in the heart of Murray Hill. The choice of this location is strategic, offering both accessibility and visibility. It’s conveniently positioned for locals and tourists alike, with easy access to public transportation and pedestrian-friendly surroundings. The area is known for its vibrant atmosphere, making it an excellent spot for a meal out.

Elegant and Cozy Interior

Upon entering, guests are greeted by an elegant and cozy interior. The design includes subdued lighting that contributes to a warm and inviting atmosphere. A beautiful gas fireplace accents the dining room, providing both comfort and a touch of sophistication. Whether you’re dining alone, on a date, or celebrating a special occasion, this ambiance fosters a relaxing experience that feels both intimate and upscale.

Convenient Parking Options

Accessibility is further emphasized with the convenient parking options, ensuring that visitors can easily reach the restaurant without the hassle of extensive searching for parking. This aspect is particularly beneficial in a bustling city like New York, where parking can often be a challenge. With accessible parking available nearby, diners can focus on enjoying their meal while easing concerns about parking logistics.

Tip: For a more enjoyable experience, consider visiting during weekday lunches when the atmosphere is quieter and more relaxed.

A Perfect Setting for Every Occasion

Overall, this restaurant’s location and ambiance make it an ideal spot for a variety of dining occasions. Whether you’re looking to enjoy a casual dinner with friends or celebrate a milestone with family, the blend of an elegant atmosphere and cozy features will accommodate your needs perfectly. With the addition of convenient parking and a prime location in Murray Hill, this restaurant presents a highly accessible and delightful dining experience.

Menu Highlights

When it comes to dining at this charming restaurant, the menu highlights represent the essence of Italian cuisine, featuring a blend of classic offerings that never disappoint. The dishes are carefully crafted to evoke authentic flavors, making every meal a delightful experience for food enthusiasts.

Classic Italian Options

Among the classic Italian options available, signature dishes such as chicken scarpariello, veal cutlets Florentine, and risotto del giorno take center stage. Each dish is prepared using traditional techniques, ensuring that the flavors are rich and engaging. For instance, the chicken scarpariello is known for its tender meat, vibrant seasoning, and a perfectly balanced sauce that lingers on the palate.

Value with Prix Fixe Menu

For those looking for a great deal, the restaurant offers a prix fixe menu. Typically priced under $25, this menu provides a fantastic opportunity to indulge in multiple courses without breaking the bank. First-time diners and returning patrons alike will appreciate the value, as it allows them to sample a variety of dishes. This thoughtful pricing strategy positions the restaurant as a competitive option for lunch, catering to professionals and visitors in the area.

Dietary Options

While the menu caters to various dietary preferences, it’s essential to note that gluten-free pasta is not available. However, there are still ample vegetarian options that delight without compromising on taste. Diners looking for lighter fare or those adhering to vegetarian diets can explore delicious alternatives crafted from fresh ingredients, showcasing the restaurant’s commitment to quality.

Pro Tip: Pair your meal with a glass of wine from the extensive selection to enhance your dining experience and fully enjoy the flavors of each dish.

In essence, the menu highlights at this restaurant not only showcase the heart of Italian culinary traditions but also promote accessibility and value for patrons seeking a memorable dining experience. With options that cater to diverse tastes and preferences, it stands as a key player in the local culinary scene.

Service and Experience

When dining out, the service experience can significantly enhance or diminish your overall enjoyment. At this restaurant, customers frequently note that the service is often friendly and professional, ensuring that patrons feel welcomed and valued from the moment they step inside. Although individual experiences can vary, many reviews highlight the attentiveness of the staff, which greatly contributes to a pleasant dining atmosphere.

A Quiet Atmosphere

The ambience at this venue is designed to be quiet and soothing, making it an excellent choice for both casual dining and special occasions. As you enter, you’ll find that the subdued lighting and elegant decor create a cozy environment that invites relaxation and conversation. This peaceful setting is especially appealing for those seeking a break from the hustle and bustle of New York City life. In fact, many diners express their appreciation for a restaurant where they can enjoy their meals without the interference of excessive noise.

Hot and Fresh Food

In addition to a welcoming atmosphere and professional service, the quality of the food is critical in defining a satisfying dining experience. Here, food is typically served hot and freshly prepared, reflecting the care and attention the kitchen staff invests in each item on the menu. Diners can look forward to enjoying dishes that not only taste great but also arrive at their tables in perfect condition. This commitment to freshness is especially noteworthy and plays a significant role in influencing overall satisfaction.

Pro Tip: For the best service experience, consider dining during off-peak hours, when the staff can offer more personalized attention.

To summarize, the service and experience at this restaurant create a harmonious combination that leaves guests feeling valued and satisfied. With friendly service, a tranquil atmosphere, and delectable food, it’s no wonder many diners choose this spot for their culinary needs. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick lunch or enjoying a leisurely dinner, you can expect an overall enjoyable experience that’s hard to beat.

Visitor Feedback Summary

When it comes to evaluating dining experiences, visitor feedback plays a significant role. This restaurant has garnered an overall rating of 3.5 out of 5 based on various reviews from patrons. This rating suggests a blend of positive and average experiences, pointing towards a generally satisfactory meal but with room for improvement.

High Praise for Specific Dishes

One of the most commendable aspects of the dining experience here is the quality of certain dishes. For example, many diners have lavished praise on the mozzarella en carozza, a traditional Italian dish that features melted mozzarella nestled between two slices of bread, creating a crispy delight that enchants the palate. Additionally, the chicken parmigiana has been highlighted as a must-try, with its perfectly breaded chicken breast topped with marinara sauce and gooey cheese. Such dishes not only bring authentic flavors to the table but are also crafted with care, making them standout options on the menu.

Critiques on Portion Sizes

On the other hand, several patrons have expressed concerns regarding portion sizes. While the quality of the dishes received acclaim, diners have suggested that larger servings would enhance their dining experience. This aspect indicates a potential area for growth, as satisfied guests tend to return when they feel they are receiving ample food for the price paid. Many customers have reportedly requested bigger portions, particularly for hearty Italian favorites that typically come in generous sizes elsewhere.

“A mix of great flavors and a cozy atmosphere, but more food on the plate would be welcomed!” – Frequent Diner

In conclusion, the visitor feedback summary paints a picture of a restaurant that excels in certain areas, particularly with specific dishes, while also highlighting opportunities for enhancement. As these factors continue to evolve, it will be intriguing to see how guest experiences potentially shift and improve over time.

Practical Details

Address and Location

If you’re planning to visit this delightful restaurant, it is conveniently located at 635 2nd Ave, between 34th & 35th streets, New York City, NY 10016-4862. This central location in the bustling Murray Hill neighborhood makes it easy to access for both locals and tourists.

Contact Information

For inquiries or reservations, you can reach the restaurant directly at +1 212-686-3400. It’s advisable to call ahead, especially during peak dining hours, to ensure you have a spot for your desired time.

Operating Hours

The restaurant is open for lunch and dinner daily, offering flexibility whether you’re looking for a midday meal or a relaxed evening dining experience. Here is a brief overview of the operating hours:

How to Get There

If you are not familiar with the area, don’t worry! The restaurant’s location is easily traceable via Google Maps. You can find directions here. This link will direct you straight to the map for easy navigation to one of Murray Hill’s culinary gems.

Pro Tip: Arrive early during lunch hours for the best seating and a chance to enjoy their prix fixe menu!

In summary, these practical details should make your dining experience both enjoyable and stress-free. Make sure to take note of the address, contact information, and operating hours when planning your visit. Happy dining!

Notaro in New York City is a delightful spot for anyone craving Italian cuisine in a cozy setting. From expertly prepared dishes to a warm atmosphere, it promises a lovely dining experience. While service may fluctuate, the quality of the food and overall ambiance make it worth a visit. Don’t hesitate to stop by and enjoy the flavors of Italy right in the heart of Murray Hill!

Frequently Asked Questions